Skip to content
Federal Criminal Trialtrial-daytrial-dayMaurene ComeyLara PomerantzLaura A. MenningerJeffrey S. PagliucaCarolynStephen FlatleyKimberly MedersidebardirectcrossredirectrecrossDay 7 - December 7, 2021Carolyn testified about appointments she said Maxwell arranged at Jeffrey Epstein's Palm Beach house and was cross-examined with prior accounts and compensation materials. The court also heard digital-forensics testimony about photographs, drive imaging, and document metadata, while delaying Brian's anticipated testimony pending an inquiry into his communication with Jane.
← Day 6Federal Criminal TrialDay 8 →

Day 7 - December 7, 2021

Carolyn Testifies; Digital Evidence Examined; Brian Testimony Delayed

Judge Alison J. Nathan
14Proceedings
4Pages
3Witnesses
3,658Lines
Day 7 of 19
Appearing:

Carolyn testified about appointments she said Maxwell arranged at Jeffrey Epstein's Palm Beach house and was cross-examined with prior accounts and compensation materials. The court also heard digital-forensics testimony about photographs, drive imaging, and document metadata, while delaying Brian's anticipated testimony pending an inquiry into his communication with Jane.

Full day summary

The court addressed a reported communication between Jane and her brother Brian, postponing Brian's anticipated testimony while the parties investigated whether it implicated the sequestration order. The government later said it would not call Brian that evening because its factual inquiry was incomplete. FBI examiner Kimberly Meder identified photographs from investigation CDs, and the court admitted photographic exhibits, including two under seal. On cross-examination, Meder said she did not know how the photographs reached the CDs, who took them, whether disc dates were accurate, or whether images had been altered. FBI digital-forensics examiner Stephen Flatley then described imaging a drive and comparing hash values, and identified documents stored in a folder for the user Ghislaine. On cross, he said the Word author field reflected user-entered account information and did not establish who was at the computer; he also could not identify the source of the cloned drive or who had access to the computer. Carolyn testified that Virginia brought her to Jeffrey Epstein's Palm Beach house when she was 14, that Maxwell initially arranged massage appointments, and that Maxwell continued arranging them after Carolyn said she was 14. She described returning to the house more than 100 times, the sexual conduct she said occurred during the appointments, and an interaction with Maxwell in the massage room. On cross-examination, defense counsel used prior FBI, civil-case, deposition, and compensation-fund materials; Carolyn disputed or qualified parts of those accounts. The court allowed selected impeachment material while sustaining objections to other excerpts. After recross, the court also directed counsel to state concise objection grounds without communicating with witnesses or jurors through objections.

2. Kimberly Meder — Direct/Cross/Redirect (Continued)

Kimberly Meder identified investigation photographs as the court admitted Government exhibits; cross-examination addressed the limits of her personal knowledge about the CDs and images before she was excused.

Direct
Kimberly MederMaurene Comey
351 lines

Kimberly Meder identified photographs from investigation CDs as the court admitted a series of Government exhibits, including two under seal.

Cross
Kimberly MederLaura A. Menninger
121 lines

The defense emphasized that Kimberly Meder reviewed thousands of photographs but lacked personal knowledge of their provenance, dates, alteration, and accuracy.

Redirect
Kimberly MederMaurene Comey
23 lines

Two sustained hearsay objections ended Kimberly Meder's brief redirect without further testimony.

3. Stephen Flatley — Direct/Cross/Redirect/Recross

FBI examiner Stephen Flatley described the forensic imaging of a hard drive and metadata tied to a Ghislaine user account, while cross-examination addressed limits on identifying who used the computer.

Direct
Stephen FlatleyLara Pomerantz
339 lines

Stephen Flatley authenticated electronic records from Government Exhibit 54 and identified document metadata and a Ghislaine user folder.

Cross
Stephen FlatleyLaura A. Menninger
175 lines

Stephen Flatley acknowledged limits on identifying the original cloned drive, the computer's location, document authorship, and who could access the computer.

Redirect
Stephen FlatleyLara Pomerantz
8 lines

Stephen Flatley said all reviewed Exhibit 54 emails were from the gmax1@mindspring.com account.

Recross
Stephen FlatleyLaura A. Menninger
46 lines

Stephen Flatley agreed that an email client may refresh and populate emails when a computer connects to the internet.

Highlights

4. Carolyn — Direct/Cross/Redirect/Recross

Carolyn’s testimony described her recruitment at age 14, repeated visits to Jeffrey Epstein’s Palm Beach house, and interactions she attributed to Ghislaine Maxwell; defense questioning examined earlier accounts and compensation records.

Direct
CarolynMaurene Comey
908 lines

Carolyn testified that Maxwell arranged appointments at Jeffrey Epstein's Palm Beach house and described repeated paid, sexualized massage encounters beginning when she was 14.

Cross
CarolynJeffrey S. Pagliuca
1471 lines

Defense challenged Carolyn with earlier statements and filings, while the court limited some impeachment evidence and allowed selected complaint and interrogatory excerpts.

Redirect
CarolynMaurene Comey
43 lines

Carolyn addressed prior records, her age when she first encountered Maxwell and Epstein, and her stated reasons for testifying.

Recross
CarolynJeffrey S. Pagliuca
80 lines

Carolyn denied losing all of the money referenced on recross before the government withdrew Brian as a planned witness and the court addressed scheduling and objections.

Highlights

← Day 6Federal Criminal TrialDay 8 →