Skip to content
Ghislaine Maxwell- Case Archive
Federal Criminal Trialtrial-daytrial-dayMaurene ComeyLara PomerantzAndrew RohrbachLaura A. MenningerJeffrey S. PagliucaLisa RocchioJuan Patricio AlessiPaul KanedirectcrossredirectDay 4 - December 2, 2021Dr. Lisa Rocchio gave general expert testimony on grooming and delayed disclosure, and Juan Alessi described Palm Beach household operations and instructions he attributed to Ghislaine Maxwell.
← Day 3Federal Criminal TrialDay 5 →

Day 4 - December 2, 2021

Expert Testimony on Grooming; Alessi Describes Palm Beach Household Operations

Judge Alison J. Nathan
14Proceedings
4Pages
3Witnesses
2,708Lines
4Sidebars
Day 4 of 19
Appearing:
Maurene Comey Lara Pomerantz Andrew Rohrbach Laura A. Menninger Jeffrey S. Pagliuca Lisa Rocchio Juan Patricio Alessi Paul Kane

Dr. Lisa Rocchio gave general expert testimony on grooming and delayed disclosure, and Juan Alessi described Palm Beach household operations and instructions he attributed to Ghislaine Maxwell.

Full day summary

Before the jury entered on Day 4, the parties argued over the anticipated admission of household and contact-book exhibits, and Judge Alison J. Nathan reserved ruling pending testimony. A school administrator authenticated an enrollment application admitted under seal. Dr. Lisa Rocchio then gave general expert testimony about grooming, coercion, and delayed disclosure, while the court limited portions of the examination and instructed the jury to disregard responses outside the permitted scope. On cross-examination, Rocchio said she had not evaluated parties or reviewed case-specific witness material. Juan Patricio Alessi testified about running Jeffrey Epstein's Palm Beach household and receiving daily instructions from Ghislaine Maxwell. He described household diagrams, an instruction booklet, transportation of Jane and Virginia Roberts, and the scheduling and cleanup of massages. The court admitted Exhibit 606 after voir dire, reserved a separate ruling on Exhibit 52 after sustaining a foundation objection, and admitted portions of a message-booklet exhibit under seal. Alessi also testified about returning to the house after his employment ended, taking $6,300, and repaying it under an agreement with Epstein.

1. Exhibits 52 and 606 Admissibility Hearing

Counsel debated the possible admission of a household manual and contact book before the jury entered, and Judge Nathan deferred a ruling pending further testimony.

→
Procedural
Exhibits 52 and 606 Admissibility Hearing
47 lines

Counsel disputed anticipated admission of two exhibits, and Judge Nathan deferred ruling until testimony and possible voir dire.

2. Paul Kane — Direct/Cross/Redirect

Paul Kane authenticated and read from a school enrollment application that the court admitted under seal, then testified that separate records would show any tuition payments.

→
Direct
Paul Kane — Direct Paul Kane Andrew Rohrbach
129 lines

Kane authenticated a school enrollment application; Judge Nathan overruled a business-records objection and admitted Government Exhibit 761 under seal.

1 sidebar inside this proceeding
  1. Exhibit 761 Business Records ObjectionThe parties disputed whether an admissions application containing third-party information qualified as a business record.
Cross
Paul Kane — Cross Paul Kane Laura A. Menninger
55 lines

Defense cross-examination tested the limits of Paul Kane's knowledge about the enrollment application, and Judge Nathan restricted reading an agent's name aloud.

Redirect
Paul Kane — Redirect Paul Kane Andrew Rohrbach
12 lines

Paul Kane said financial records are kept separately from student files, then was excused.

3. Lisa Rocchio — Direct/Cross/Redirect

Dr. Lisa Rocchio completed general expert testimony about traumatic stress, grooming, and delayed disclosure, with Judge Nathan sustaining objections that limited portions of the examination.

→
Direct
Lisa Rocchio — Direct Lisa Rocchio Lara Pomerantz
449 lines

Dr. Rocchio gave general expert testimony on grooming and delayed disclosure as the court enforced limits on her opinions and set boundaries for cross-examination.

2 sidebars inside this proceeding
  1. Limits on Clinical Treatment TestimonyCounsel disputed whether an expert could discuss specific treatment experiences as support for her opinions on grooming and delayed disclosure.
  2. Expert Testimony BoundaryAt sidebar, the court concluded that questioning about a third party approached a previously precluded area of expert testimony.
Cross
Lisa Rocchio — Cross Lisa Rocchio Jeffrey S. Pagliuca
203 lines

Defense tested Dr. Rocchio's expert limits and literature on grooming; she said grooming is a pattern and cannot be reliably predicted prospectively.

Redirect
Lisa Rocchio — Redirect Lisa Rocchio Lara Pomerantz
20 lines

Judge Nathan sustained a scope objection on redirect, and Dr. Rocchio was excused.

Highlights

Lisa Rocchio — Directtestimony highlightDr. Rocchio gave general expert testimony describing grooming as a five-stage process involving selection, access and isolation, trust-building, desensitization, and control.Lisa Rocchio — Crosstestimony highlightDefense established that Dr. Rocchio had not evaluated parties, interviewed prosecution witnesses, reviewed witness statements, or offered opinions on what happened in the case or on witness credibility.Lisa Rocchio — Cross“grooming is not a specific behavior. It's a series and a pattern of behavior that's taking into account the entire pattern.”— Lisa RocchioStates the witness's distinction between isolated conduct and the grooming framework.

4. Juan Patricio Alessi — Direct/Cross/Voir Dire

Juan Patricio Alessi continued describing household operations at the Palm Beach residence as the court admitted several exhibits and reserved a ruling on Exhibit 52 after foundation objections.

→
Direct
Juan Patricio Alessi — Direct Juan Patricio Alessi Maurene Comey
673 lines

Juan Patricio Alessi described his work running Epstein's Palm Beach house, Maxwell's daily household instructions, and the residence layouts admitted into evidence.

Cross
Juan Patricio Alessi — Exhibit 606 Voir Dire Juan Patricio Alessi Jeffrey S. Pagliuca
42 lines

Alessi described limits on his knowledge of Exhibit 606's history, and Judge Nathan admitted the exhibit.

Direct
Juan Patricio Alessi — Direct Juan Patricio Alessi Maurene Comey
576 lines

Alessi described household directories, transportation involving Jane and Virginia Roberts, and massage scheduling; the court addressed foundation for Exhibit 52.

sidebar
Exhibit 52 Foundation Objection
32 lines

Judge Nathan sustained the foundation objection and instructed the jury to disregard testimony that Exhibit 52 was a later version of the directory; its admission remained pending.

Cross
Juan Patricio Alessi — Exhibit 52 Voir Dire Juan Patricio Alessi Jeffrey S. Pagliuca
210 lines

Defense tested Alessi's knowledge of Exhibit 52's history, Judge Nathan reserved the issue, and Alessi identified parts of a message-book exhibit.

Procedural
Exhibit 2 Admissibility Hearing
37 lines

Judge Nathan admitted Exhibit 2A and admitted Exhibits 2C through 2W under seal after overruling defense objections.

Direct
Juan Patricio Alessi — Direct Juan Patricio Alessi Maurene Comey
223 lines

Alessi testified that he stored a sex toy found after Epstein's massages in Maxwell's closet, saw topless photographs at her desk, and saw her using a camera. He acknowledged taking $6,300 from the house after leaving employment and repaying it.

Highlights

Juan Patricio Alessi — Directtestimony highlightAlessi testified that Maxwell gave him instructions daily while he ran Epstein's Palm Beach house, including directions about cleaning, service, shopping, and household operations.Juan Patricio Alessi — Direct“Because I had all the orders from Mr. Epstein where I suppose it was passed to Ms. Maxwell, and she would interact with me directly.”— Juan Patricio AlessiAlessi described Maxwell as his direct point of contact for household instructions.Juan Patricio Alessi — Directtestimony highlightAlessi described picking Jane up for visits to the Palm Beach house and driving her, Epstein, and Maxwell to the plane on occasions when Jane had luggage.Juan Patricio Alessi — Directtestimony highlightAlessi testified that he scheduled massages from a Rolodex at the direction of Maxwell, Epstein, or the New York office, and that massages could be scheduled late at night.
← Day 3Federal Criminal TrialDay 5 →