Skip to content
Ghislaine Maxwell- Case Archive
Federal Criminal TrialtranscripttranscriptLimiting Instruction on Exhibit 52 - Day 10 - Federal Criminal TrialJudge Nathan limited the jury's use of Exhibit 52, admitted related exhibits and a public stipulation, and sustained a defense objection concerning selected entries in Exhibit 52G.
Alison MoeAndrew RohrbachJeffrey S. PagliucaAlison J. NathanWilliam BrownJudge NathanMs. MoeMr. PagliucaMr. RohrbachWilliam Brownjury_instructions
Federal Criminal Trial/Day 10/December 10, 2021
7 pages·4 witnesses·3,633 lines
Judge Nathan limited the jury's use of Exhibit 52, admitted related exhibits and a public stipulation, and sustained a defense objection concerning selected entries in Exhibit 52G.
← Day 9
Day 11 →
Jury Instruction

Limiting Instruction on Exhibit 52

28 lines
Jury InstructionJury Instr.Limiting Instruction on Exhibit 52
1

JUDGE NATHAN: Members of the jury, the exhibit is being offered for a limited purpose. They were not being offered for the truth of the matters asserted therein, and you may not consider it for that purpose. Rather, you may consider them only to the extent you believe it is relevant to show a link, if any, between Ms. Maxwell and the names and phone numbers listed and how, if at all, the information was organized.

2

MS. MOE: Thank you, your Honor. And may these exhibits be received under seal to protect the identities of witnesses testifying under pseudonyms and the privacy of third parties?

3

JUDGE NATHAN: No objection to the sealing?

4

MR. PAGLIUCA: No objection.

5

JUDGE NATHAN: For the reasons indicated, they are admitted under seal.

6

MS. MOE: May the jurors turn to what's now in evidence under seal as Government Exhibits 52G, which is in their binders.

7

JUDGE NATHAN: Without objection?

8

MR. PAGLIUCA: No objection.

9

JUDGE NATHAN: Large binders, GX52G, please.

10

MS. MOE: Thank you, your Honor. May the jurors have a moment to read this exhibit. In particular, we would direct the jurors' attention to the entries under massage, Florida, for --

11

MR. PAGLIUCA: Your Honor, I object to the direction here.

12

JUDGE NATHAN: Sustained. They can review the document.

13

MS. MOE: Thank you, your Honor. May we give the jurors a few minutes to read the document in full?

15

MS. MOE: 52G, your Honor, yes.

16

JUDGE NATHAN: They can take a moment for 52G, yes.

17

(Pause) Okay.

18

MS. MOE: Thank you, your Honor. Finally, we would offer Government Exhibit 1009. This stipulation is a public exhibit.

19

JUDGE NATHAN: Without objection and on stipulation, 1009 is admitted.

20

MR. PAGLIUCA: Yes, your Honor.

21

JUDGE NATHAN: Thank you.

22

MS. MOE: Thank you, your Honor.

23

JUDGE NATHAN: Jurors may put the binders down and the government may call its next witness.

24

MR. ROHRBACH: The government calls William Brown.

25

JUDGE NATHAN: William Brown may come forward. WILLIAM BROWN, called as a witness by the Government, having been duly sworn, testified as follows:

26

JUDGE NATHAN: Thank you, Mr. Brown. You may be seated and you may remove your mask and please state and spell your name for the record.

27

WILLIAM BROWN: Thank you. My name is William Brown, W-i-l-l-i-a-m B-r-o-w-n.

28

JUDGE NATHAN: Mr. Rohrbach, you may inquire.

Continue to next pageWilliam Brown — Rebuttal Testimony
← Day 9
Day 11 →
← Exhibit 52, William Brown Rebuttal Motion, and Sealed Jury Follow-Up2 of 7William Brown — Rebuttal Testimony →